If you visit John’s Pizzeria in Times Square and walk all the way inside, you’ll be greeted by a breathtaking sight—a massive, eight-sided dome with a stunning stained glass ceiling. This architectural masterpiece gives the pizzeria a truly one-of-a-kind atmosphere, blending history with the lively energy of New York City.
From Gospel Tabernacle to Pizza Haven
Originally built in 1888, the building was once home to the Gospel Tabernacle Church. The surrounding structure served as a missionary college and bookstore, playing a key role in the community. The church thrived in Times Square until 1970, when it relocated to the Eastside, leaving the historic building abandoned. For years, it fell into disrepair, occupied by squatters and neglected.
The Vision of Madeline Castellotti
In 1997, entrepreneur Madeline Castellotti saw the potential in this forgotten space. According to John’s Pizzeria’s website, what captivated her most was the perfectly intact stained glass ceiling. The design, made up of eight equal sections, reminded her of a pizza pie. It was at that moment she knew this would be the home of her dream—creating the most unique pizzeria in the world.
A Blend of Art and History
Beyond its iconic dome, John’s Pizzeria also features an enormous mural, a panoramic view of Manhattan created by artist Douglas Cooper. This artwork adds another layer of character to an already extraordinary space, making it more than just a place to eat—it’s an experience.
The Largest Pizzeria in the U.S.?
John’s Pizzeria proudly claims to be the largest pizzeria in the country, housed in a church that has stood for over 134 years. Whether you visit for the delicious coal-fired pizza or to admire the historic setting, this transformed church remains one of Times Square’s most fascinating hidden treasures.